Islay Robinson explores why borrowers with complex income structures can struggle to secure mortgages, examining lender criteria, affordability assessments and the importance of choosing the right financing partner.

The traditional picture of a mortgage borrower is changing. More people now earn through a combination of business income, bonuses, shares, overseas earnings and multiple income streams. Yet the mortgage market has not always kept pace with the way people work and manage their finances.

Research published by Nottingham Building Society as part of its The Doorstep Divide report surveyed more than 500 mortgage brokers. It found that 68% expect borrowers with non-standard financial circumstances to become the new normal, while 88% believe lenders have been too slow to adapt. Almost a third already consider these borrowers the norm, with a further 49% expecting this within the next 12 months.

The research also highlights where applications encounter difficulties. Brokers identified initial affordability assessments and evidence or documentation requirements as the most common reasons viable complex-income applications stall, with 19% citing each. A further 18% said differing evidence requirements between lenders were the biggest barrier to placing a case.

The word I would underline is viable. These are applications that brokers consider financially sound but which still encounter problems during the assessment process. That is different from a borrower who simply cannot afford the mortgage. A separate survey of 2,000 UK adults, included in the same research, highlighted similar concerns from the borrowers' perspective.

Why Complex-Income Applications Can Be Difficult

The most revealing figure in this research is the 18% who identified differing evidence requirements between lenders as the biggest barrier. It illustrates how the same borrower can receive different decisions depending on which lender assesses their application.

For someone earning a straightforward monthly salary, the assessment process may be relatively simple. For a business owner, contractor or individual receiving income in several currencies, it can be considerably more involved.

Some lenders may assess company profits, dividends and retained earnings differently. Others may take a different approach to bonuses, commission, share awards or overseas income. The documents required to demonstrate affordability can also vary.

This is why choosing the right lender matters at least as much as choosing the mortgage product. An application that does not fit one lender's criteria may be suitable for another, depending on how that lender assesses income, affordability and supporting evidence.

Why Preparation Matters for Borrowers With Multiple Income Sources

For borrowers whose income does not come from a single salary, preparation can make a substantial difference.

Business owners, for example, may need to demonstrate income through a combination of salary, dividends and company accounts. Someone paid in more than one currency may need to provide evidence of overseas earnings and explain how those payments are received. Individuals whose remuneration includes bonuses or shares may need to demonstrate how regularly those payments are made and whether they can reasonably be expected to continue.

Lenders do not all assess these income sources in the same way. Some may place greater weight on historical earnings, while others may consider more recent financial information or take a different view of variable income.

I would rather spend time establishing how a lender will assess an applicant's income before submitting an application than deal with a decline afterwards. Understanding the evidence required, how income will be calculated and which criteria apply can help avoid unnecessary delays.

Can Historic Credit Issues Prevent Someone From Getting a Mortgage?

The research also raises an important point about credit history. Some 89% of brokers believe lenders should give greater weight to a borrower's current financial stability than to a historic credit issue that has since been resolved.

I agree with the principle. A resolved financial difficulty from several years ago should not automatically outweigh a borrower's current income, financial commitments and ability to maintain mortgage repayments.

However, lenders have different approaches to historic credit issues. Some may be more flexible about the circumstances surrounding a previous missed payment or adverse credit event, while others may apply stricter criteria or require more time to have passed.

The important distinction is between understanding what happened and assessing the borrower's current position. A lender needs to consider the full circumstances rather than relying on a single element of an applicant's financial history.

What Recent Regulatory Changes Mean for Mortgage Borrowers

There have also been changes to the regulatory framework for higher loan-to-income mortgage lending.

On 28 October 2026, the Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority implemented changes removing the individual 15% cap that previously applied to each lender's high loan-to-income mortgage lending. The overall market limit, based on the Financial Policy Committee's recommendation, remains in place. The PRA's policy statement sets out the changes.

This gives individual lenders greater flexibility to decide how much higher loan-to-income lending they undertake, subject to their own risk appetite and the wider regulatory framework. It does not mean that lenders have to increase this type of lending or that borrowers are automatically entitled to borrow more.

Separately, there has been reporting about a possible increase in the high loan-to-income threshold from 4.5 to five times income. However, the Financial Policy Committee has not announced a decision or timetable for such a change. The existing 4.5-times-income definition therefore remains relevant.

For borrowers with complex financial circumstances, these developments are worth watching. Greater flexibility among lenders could create more scope for different lending approaches, but affordability assessments and individual lender criteria will continue to determine what is available.

Why Comparing Lenders Matters

At Enness Global, we work with a network of more than 1,000 lenders, including private banks. This gives us the opportunity to compare how different lenders approach complex income, overseas earnings, business ownership and historic credit issues.

There is no guarantee that an application will be accepted, and each lender makes its own decision. However, understanding the differences in their criteria can help identify potential routes that may not be obvious from a standard mortgage search.

I am not claiming that lenders will adapt overnight. The survey suggests that brokers have been waiting for the market to catch up with borrowers' changing financial circumstances. But the need for more flexible assessment is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

For borrowers with multiple income sources or a less conventional financial profile, the right preparation and lender selection can make a meaningful difference. The starting point should not simply be how much someone wants to borrow, but how their income, financial history and wider circumstances will be assessed by the lender.

Important Information

This article is for general information only and does not constitute personal financial or mortgage advice. Mortgage availability, rates and lending criteria depend on individual circumstances and lender requirements, and no application is guaranteed to be accepted. Enness Global is a credit broker, not a lender. Not all mortgages and private bank facilities are regulated by the FCA; some specialist, buy-to-let, commercial and overseas borrowing is unregulated. Speak to a qualified adviser before making a financial decision.

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage. Think carefully before securing other debts against your home.

Enness Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 565120).

FAQs

What Is A Complex-Income Mortgage?

A complex-income mortgage is designed for borrowers with income from sources such as business profits, dividends, bonuses, shares or overseas earnings.

Can I Get A Mortgage If I Have Multiple Income Sources?

Yes, some lenders consider multiple income sources when assessing affordability. Their criteria and documentation requirements vary, so choosing the right lender is important.

Can I Get A Mortgage With A Previous Credit Issue?

A resolved credit issue does not automatically prevent mortgage approval. Lenders assess the circumstances, how long ago it occurred and your current financial position.